Which Sunscreens Do More Harm Than Good?

The Environmental Working Group came out with their famous Sunscreen Guide 2012.  There seems to be so much confusion with the results of many studies.  Some say sunscreens protect against certain types of cancer.  Others say they do little.  While it is agreed that sunscreens protect against sunburn, there is little evidence to support the efficacy or safety of many of the ingredients.

In general, it is agreed to avoid the following type of sunscreens:

  • Sprays (causes inhalation of sunscreen which may not be safe to breathe)
  • Powders (causes inhalation of sunscreen which may not be safe to breathe)
  • SPF above 50+ (may suppress burns a little but cause other skin damage)

Use these types of sunscreens:

Cream

Broad spectrum protection

Water resistant

SPF 30 for beach and pool

Ingredients matter.  Avoid using sunscreens with the following ingredients:

Oxybenzone (synthetic estrogen-yikes!)

Vitamin A or retinyl palmitat (can cause tumors or lesions-double yikes!)

Added insect repellant

Use sunscreens with these ingredients:

Zinc

Titanium dioxide

Avobenzone or Mexoryl SX

Bottom line, with the thousands of sunscreens to choose from, why have skin cancer rates stayed the same or even increased?  Could some of the ingredients of these sunscreens even contribute to skin cancer?  I choose to listen to the unbiased experts at EWG and follow the guidelines aboveor the top and worst sunscreens below.  Then again, a big old hat and shade may be the safest option of all!

Check out some of EWGs top safest and most effective sunscreens:

Adorable Baby

Alba Botanica

All Terrain

Aubrey Organics

Badger

BurnOut

ECO logical skin care

Kiss My

FaceRaw Elements

Seventh Generation

 AVOID some of these worst offenders:

Banana Boat Kids Quik Sunblock Apray Lotion. SPF 35 (4% oxybenzone)

Coppertone Water Babies Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 70+ (6% oxybenzone)

Banana Boat Baby Tear Free Sunblock, SPF 50 (contain retinyl palmitate)

Arbonne Baby Care Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 30 (contain retinly palmitate)

Australian Gold Baby Formula Lotion, SPF 50 (contain retinyl palmitate)

Neutrogena Wet Skin Kids Beach and Pool, SPF 70(nothing “safer” over SPF 50)

CVS Kids Fast Cover Continuous Spray, SPF 50(sprays pose serious inhalation risk)

Rite Aid Baby Continuous Spray, SPF 50 (sprays pose serious inhalation risk)

Go!screen Natural Mineral PowderBlock Brush-On, SPF 30 (possible carcinogen  when inhaled)

Aveeno Naturals Continuous Protection Sunblock Fact Lotion, SPF 30

Coppertone UltraGuard

For the full report, check out http://breakingnews.ewg.org/2012sunscreen/

 

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *